Motivation for Weight Loss: Why Your Why Matters Most

just a photo

Be honest. What was the very first reason you gave yourself?

The wedding. The reunion. The jeans folded at the back of the wardrobe, waiting patiently since 2019. The photo someone tagged you in that you untagged in four seconds flat.

Those reasons are completely human. And they work. For about six weeks.

Then life happens. A deadline. A plateau. Suddenly “looking good in the photos” isn’t enough motivation for weight loss to get you out of bed for a walk.

So what does keep people going? I found the answer somewhere I didn’t expect.

What positive psychology taught me about motivation

Studying positive psychology changed how I consult completely.

One of the big ideas in the field is self-determination theory. The short version: there are two kinds of motivation.

  • Extrinsic motivation is doing something for a reward outside yourself. Praise. Approval. A smaller size.

  • Intrinsic motivation is doing something because it matters to you. Your health. Your people. Feeling capable and clear-headed.

Our culture shouts extrinsic goals at us, especially about bodies. So many of us set goals in someone else’s voice, then wonder why we can’t stick to them.

A real story from my clinic

John (not his real name) is a 54-year-old executive who walked into my clinic tired but wired, living on flat whites, boardroom biscuits and late client dinners. His energy crashed every afternoon (sound familiar? Here’s the 3pm slump explained).

“John, why do you want to lose weight?”

“I want to lose 22 kilos for my wife and my family.”

So I asked him to write down three reasons that really mattered to him. He paused.

“I want to be healthy so I can be attractive to my wife, have energy to travel, and stay mentally sharp amongst my younger peers at work.”

Feel the difference? Twenty-two kilos is a maths problem on a bathroom scale. Feeling close to the person you love, travelling well and staying sharp in a room full of younger colleagues? That’s a life.

Once John anchored to those reasons, his habits clicked: protein first at breakfast and business lunches, real food instead of afternoon sugar, and weights twice a week. And he booked a hiking trip with his wife.

What the research says about motivation and keeping weight off

This isn’t just theory.

In a classic weight program study, people whose reasons felt like their own attended more often and lost more weight. They also kept more of it off almost two years later.

A Portuguese team then followed 154 women for three years and tested 28 possible predictors of who ended up at least 10% lighter. The strongest? Exercising because they genuinely wanted to, not because they felt they should.

Translation: the “should” runs out. The “want to” keeps going. So choose movement you actually enjoy. Dancing in the kitchen counts. Punishment cardio doesn’t, because you won’t keep doing it.

Why your why matters on a GLP-1 medication too

On a GLP-1 medication, things change along the way: a new dose, side effects, a plateau, or a decision with your doctor to reduce or stop.

Your why is the part that stays steady through all of it. It belongs entirely to you, whatever your treatment plan looks like.

You don’t need to be “skinny” to be healthier

For some people, chasing “skinny” is a de-motivator. It doesn’t fit who they are.

Good news: health gains don’t start at a magic number. A study of more than 5,000 adults with type 2 diabetes looked at modest weight loss. Losing 5 to 10% of body weight was linked to better blood sugar, blood pressure and blood fats. For someone who weighs 100 kilos, that’s 5 to 10 kilos. Just a healthier version of you.

Two check-in questions I love: Do I feel better? And do I still feel like me? (More on that in food freedom: why you don’t need to be perfect.)

How to find your why: five micro habits

  1. The “says who?” test. Write your goals down. Next to each, ask: whose voice is this? Keep the ones that are yours.

  2. The “so that” ladder. Ask “so that what?” three times. “Lose weight, so that I can keep up with the grandkids, so that they remember a nanna who played.” Now that’s a why.

  3. One for the mirror. You’re allowed one appearance goal. Just one.

  4. Write it, don’t think it. A why in your head is a wish. A why on paper is a plan.

  5. Keep it in sight. On the fridge, the bathroom mirror or your phone lock screen.

On a plateau, pull out the list. The scale is one number. Your whys are the whole story.

When to talk to your doctor

If you’re managing a health condition, talk to your GP about your goals and your plan. If you’re taking or considering a GLP-1 medication, talk to your GP or prescriber about what’s right for you.

Quick questions

How do I stay motivated to lose weight?

Anchor to reasons that matter to you, like energy, health and the people you love, rather than a number or a dress size. Research shows motivation that feels like your own lasts longer. Write your reasons down and keep them where you’ll see them on hard days.

What is intrinsic motivation for weight loss?

It’s doing something because it genuinely matters to you, not for approval or appearance. Wanting energy to travel or keep up with your kids is intrinsic. Wanting to look good for a reunion is extrinsic. Studies link the intrinsic kind to keeping weight off for longer.

How much weight do I need to lose to be healthier?

Less than you might think. In a large study of adults with type 2 diabetes, losing 5 to 10% of body weight was linked to better blood sugar, blood pressure and blood fats. Talk to your GP about what’s realistic and healthy for you.

This article is general information about nutrition and motivation. It is not personal medical advice.

Nourish, not punish. And let your why do the heavy lifting.

Yours in good health and some dark chocolate đŸ«


Sources

  1. Ryan RM, Deci EL (2000). Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development, and well-being. American Psychologist 55(1).

  2. Williams GC et al. (1996). Motivational predictors of weight loss and weight-loss maintenance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 70(1).

  3. Santos I et al. (2015). Predicting long-term weight loss maintenance in previously overweight women. Obesity.

  4. Wing RR et al. (2011). Benefits of modest weight loss in improving cardiovascular risk factors in overweight and obese individuals with type 2 diabetes. Diabetes Care.

GLP-1 Muscle Loss: How to Keep Your Muscle

AHV MCH image trans bg

By Michele Chevalley Hedge, Accredited Nutritionist (Adv. Dip. Nutritional Medicine, ATMS)

Michele Chevalley Hedge is an accredited nutritionist (Adv. Dip. Nutritional Medicine), author of The Healthy Hormone Diet & Eat, Drink And Still Shrink  as well as keynote speaker. She's the founder of A Healthy View, working with individuals and organisations across Australia to build sustainable health through evidence-based nutrition and positive psychology.

Read more about Michele · Explore her books· Corporate wellbeing programs

#678e9e

Ready to take the next step?

Explore our full range of wellbeing courses and start your journey today.



Explore Courses

0 comments

There are no comments yet. Be the first one to leave a comment!